Excerpt from the screed at feministe.us :
Raincitygirl Says: Standard Mischief, do you understand fucking ANYTHING about the Canadian medical system? Because I live here, and the stuff you’re saying bears no relation to the system I’ve been getting my health care from since 1978.
Seems like I do, but hey, thanks for your input!
.. You can only get 13 packs (at 28 days per pack) paid for in one year. However, when I wanted to skip my period because I was going on vacation, and thus went through my 13 pack prescription in slightly less than a year, my doctor came up with a very logical solution?
Damn, looks like I was spot on here, zuzu. Thankfully, it’s no more restricted than your average HMO here in the states. I figured it was like this the same way most people figure out which way to flick the light switch when you walk into a dark room. You don’t even think about it, most of the time just from past experience, you flick it up.
Prescriptions are handled by pharmacies, not by the government. If you have an extended health plan, often times you can get the co-payment taken off when you get your meds, [snip rest of interesting paragraph]
So you are saying the all encompassing Canadian healthcare has not yet reached prescription plans? That’s interesting. I do know, however that the Canadian government has instituted price controls on pharmaceuticals, nationwide.
I have a fair bit of choice in terms of which doctor I see, certainly much more than an American whose HMO will only allow him to see certain doctors. Possibly because universal healthcare is like one big HMO, but where NOBODY doesn’t have coverage. Yes, there are problems with the damn system, yes there are waiting lists for non-emergency care and non-life threatening surgeries, but if your doctor pisses you off you can go to another one without being restricted to the doctors of whom the HMO approves.
For this very reason, I’ve had a PPO for years. I could got to any doctor I wanted, but if I stayed on a pre-approved list, I only had to pay the copay. I never needed a referral, I could just go to a specialist if I wanted. I even had a decent prescription program. However, even though I had the very best coverage available short of visiting heads of state from corrupt third-world countries who have near unlimited funds and pay for the very best care by the hour, I still got shafted. See below.
And if you are diagnosed with cancer or another serious illness when you go to a doctor, you will always get care. In the US, if you’re unlucky enough to be diagnosed with a serious illness at your first trip to the doctor when you sign onto a health plan, that’s a pre-existing condition, and they don’t have to pay. Which means you’re probably mortgaging your house to get treatment. I have many complaints about Canada’s health care system, but I’d take living in a country where getting seriously ill doesn’t also mean you may end up bankrupt over living in the US any day. Mainly BECAUSE I am appalled that the richest country int he world, which put a man on the moon and spends billions on fighter jets, doesn’t have a public health care system.
Look, I’ve already freely admitted that the way we tend to do healthcare here in the USA has serious problems. And I haven’t even touched on what happens when you don’t have coverage.
In my case, I had just about the best coverage plan one could buy.
My GP could not figure out my problem, so he sent me to a bunch of specialist. I saw a dozen specialist on my plan’s dime, but not a single one of them spent more than fifteen minutes on me. Frequently they ordered diagnostic tests, frequently the very same tests. Two of the doctors ordered a battery of blood tests before I even saw them. I don’t “know anything” about blood test “kickbacks”, but many of the doctors employed people who’s sole job was to take blood. I think that they received payment back from the lab for every vial they drew because as soon as I instituted a strict policy of only having my blood drawn at a lab, to prevent the doctors from receiving kickbacks, the blood test batteries stopped. They were pumping my excellent coverage for cash, which drives up costs for everyone else on my system. Also, in an effort to control costs, my plan would try to disallow coverage for shit, after-the-fact of course. Oh, and I already mentioned the “drug roulette” game
.
In the end, I went around to the dozen doctors, got all my records (got in to a few nasties here. a few asserted that they weren’t my records) and hit the books. I had to cross index my results, [ed: I indexed about a 1 inch stack of lab results, including all the redundent Lymes disease tests] make lists of all the possible nasties I might have, and then I cornered my GP at my next visit. I got his full attention for about 40 minutes, and he sat down with me and we reviewed my records, and crossed out, one-by-one, the various things that I didn’t have.
In the end I made the diagnosis, he merely confirmed it. Treatment was surprisingly inexpensive, the actual diagnosis saga spanned over two years and cost thousands of dollars, most of which was redundant and was paid by my PPO. The not-so-funny thing is if they had sprung for perhaps an hour of real doctoring and a small battery of focused tests, they could have saved thousands.
If poor women in the US could afford the regular “well woman” check-ups which are a huge part of preventive medicine, and catch medical problems before they become very serious,and maybe if uninsured pregnant American women could go to the OB/GYN on a regular basis over the course of their pregnancy, the US might not have a higher infant mortality rate than Cuba. Fucking Cuba, which, may I remind you, is considered by many to be Third World country. You know which developed country on that list had the highest infant mortality rates: Latvia. That’s the only industrialized country in the entire fucking world where more babies die in infancy than in the US. And I had a roommate from Latvia. Trust me, being able to say you’re better at something than Latvia is pretty pathetic. Like an American bobsled team saying they’re better than the team from Jamaica.
I?m with you 100% on the preventive care, but the rest of this may be cooking-the-books. See this (including the comments):
www.saysuncle.com/archives/2006/05/10/the_feminine_mistake/
Raincitygirl, thank you for commenting, you have added a bunch to the discourse here. [same link as yesterday, now with bonus comments]